TKAM Comparative Analysis

To Kill A Mockingbird Comparative Analysis

Prompt: What do you think is the most important difference between the written and filmed version? How would you prove or disprove that one version of To Kill A Mockingbird is more effective in delivering its message than the other?

           I think the most important difference between the written version of To Kill A Mockingbird and the film is the over all details. The film had all of the main events the Boo Radley house in the beginning, school, the trial, and when Boo saves Scout and Jem. The film also had less characters or didn't go in depth with minor characters and their contributions to the story. The book was much more detail and somewhat more personal. The book had descriptions for each new character, no matter how important they were. In the novel the reader got to know more about the town of Maycomb, Miss Maudie, the Finch family, Mrs. Dubose, Tom Robinson, the Radley family, and many other characters. The reader was also able to go more in depth with Scout and her personality. The film had some narration, but not as much as the book. Though the movie definitely had subtle displays of minor characters and the events over the seasons, for example when Atticus shot the dog or when Mrs. Dubose made her appearance yelling at the the children in the beginning. However, overall the main story is pretty conveyed in both versions.

          In my opinion the written version of To Kill A Mockingbird was much more effective of delivering its message. I think this because the film was slightly more vague and subtle when it comes to the morals of the story. For example Atticus had a very short talk with Scout about “walking in someone else's shoes”. The film also glossed over some minor but still important parts of the book. Events such as: Mrs. Dubose and her death, Miss Maudie’s house catching on fire, the hole in the tree lasted much longer than it did in the film, Scout and her family, etc. the film just displayed the most important messages but with very little detail compared to the novel.

           The book was very personal to me. It portrayed the morals with amazing detail and personality. The film only had one so-called “Mockingbird” which was Boo Radley. The book had several: Tom Robinson, Miss Maudie, Scout, Jem, Atticus, etc. All of these characters had their own little contributions to the messages of the story. The book also really depicted how Jem and Scout were growing and maturing throughout these events. In the book Scout and Boo had a much more personal relationship. In the end of the novel you can really see how Scout was in Boo’s shoes. She all of the past events of her life from the Radley porch. She felt a connection with Boo that is unexplainable. All in all the book was much more effective in displaying Harper Lee’s messages.